CateringOur MenuDelivery

Always fresh--you won't be disappointed.

Always fresh. I can’t decide what my favorite sandwich is but the Lighthouse is definitely in the running. Great owner and friendly staff. Give them a try you won’t be disappointed. - Patrick M. (5 star review on Google)

Good subs and specials.

Sandwiches are very good. Daily specials are good. Customer service has always been good when I have been there. - Evelyn T. (4 star review on Google)

Excellent sub shop.

Excellent local sub shop. Hot and cold sub options. Call ahead ordering and to go/eat in options all available. It can get busy at peak lunch hour, but food is always fresh and worth it. Prices are on par with what a sub shop usually is at. Interior is simple and has a lot of decorations displaying other local businesses. Staff is always friendly and welcoming, owner is usually around making sure everything is on point. Definitely my preferred sub shop in the area. - Max B. (5 star review on Google)

Best subs around town!

Always delicious! Best subs around the town, and we love their chocolate chip cookies! They deliver too! - Jennifer S. (5 star review on Google)

Best subs I've had!

This sub place has the absolute best subs I’ve had. They fix them just the way you ask. The staff is friendly and the owner is just awesome. And the best part is the owner's mom's pineapple cheesecake. It is so good, and if you ask him, he will make sure he has it in house when you say you’ll be there. I will always buy my subs there. The best. - Sarah W. (5 star review on Google)

Old City Subs-South

location small3440 US 1 South
St Augustine, FL 32086

CALL:  (904) 794-2070


Old City Subs-North

location small3501A N Ponce De Leon Blvd
St Augustine, FL 32084

CALL:  (904) 547-2948


Business Hours

South: Mon-Thur:   9:00 am - 7:00 pm
Fri-Sat: 9:00 am - 8:00 pm
Sunday: Closed
North: Mon-Sat: 9:00 am - 7:00 pm
Sunday: Closed